This discography analysis is written by contributer JT of Perth, Australia (follow him at @thesonofnoone on Twitter).
DETOUR #1'Everybody's Alone'
SpotifyOK, so I haven't had time to get my head around
Live Rust yet, but I'll get there soon.
But anyway, was listening to my iPod on the way to work and 'Everybody's Alone' came on. Great fuckin' song. Unreleased at this stage, but the first
Archives box will take care of that I hope. In fact, if memory serves me correctly, Neil's recorded this song a number of times - from Crazy Horse in late '69 or early '70 (from the same sessions that gave us 'I Believe in You'), through to the original
Tonight's the Night sessions. Obviously Neil's never got the take he thought definitive enough to put on an album for us. There's a few bootlegs of the song out there for us to enjoy in the meantime.
In fact, it's through a bootleg version that I've grown to know and love this song. Recorded (IIRC) at a KQED radio (or was it TV?) session, it's sound quality is as good as you could ask for from something in that time and hopefully should be even better once we hear the 'proper' version(s).
It's such a simple song that says more than it leads on;
"If you're looking for me
You'll find me resting in the shade
Of the mountains and trees
Beneath the cool summer breeze
And I don't mind if you stay
Everybody's alone
People talking to me
Someone saying that I'm not the same
That's not so easy to be
But when I'll learn to be free
I wonder if I'll miss the pain
Everybody's alone
All I want you to know
Is that I love you so much
I can hardly stand it
When everybody's alone
Everybody's alone"
It's a testament to Neil's prodigious talent that this song never saw the light of day. It may not be a masterpiece, but such was the amount of first-class material he was pumping out around the time that it was recorded that some stuff was bound to miss the cut.
Not too much else to say but this is a great song that I'll try and put up later on today when I get home.
I give this one a
9.0
Neil Young & Crazy Horse
Live Rust (1979) SpotifyTRACKS:
1) 'Sugar Mountain' - As I said in my
Decade review, this isn't my favourite song, but despite that - Neil makes this work. He sounds far more 'into' the song than he does on the original recording. For something that was apparently one of the first songs he wrote, this isn't bad (far from it), it's just still a song which is destined to never be a favourite. Oh well, my fault.
7.02) 'I Am A Child' - Works well with the 'Sugar Mountain' intro, matching the theme of childhood well. Still not a really great song, but in the circumstances, it works far better than the original Buffalo Springfield version. For that, I can bump this version up to a
6.53) 'Comes a Time' - Not bad at all. The album's picking up a bit. I actually miss the country band on here (live versions of this are rarely better than the versions Neil cranked out in 1984 with the International Harvesters), but Neil still does as much as he can with a song that never really grabbed me enough to talk any more about it than I do.
6.54) 'After the Goldrush' - Wow, Neil labours through this one. At times he sounds like he doesn't even want to be there. But such is the beauty of the song itself, he overcomes it to give a satisfactory (but not brilliant) performance. I kinda dig the Blue Notes versions from '88 with the horns. But I guess I might be the only one with that opinion.
6.55) 'My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)' - Still brilliant. No better or worse than the
Rust Never Sleeps version, which isn't surprising since both were recorded solo, live and acoustic on the same tour. Funny that

Worked better as the opener on
Rust Never Sleeps, but still packs an awfully big punch, no matter what the setting is.
9.06) 'When You Dance I Can Really Love' - Then there was a bang! This grooves along like a treat - better than the original version. The Horse are tight and their backing vocals are straight out of The Eagles' playbook.
8.07) 'The Loner' - This is more like it. On Neil's debut album you could see this song had potential - it just took a decade to realise. There's those backing vocals again! Not much else to say except this one gets bumped up half a point.
8.58) 'The Needle & the Damage Done' - I can do without the 'Woodstock' references. Isn't the song as poignant as it can be already without a big sign above our heads saying "this song is about why drugs are bad"? Not bad, but strangely not as effective as the
Harvest version. Maybe that was a hopeful Neil back then, this is just a jaded Neil? Who knows...
7.59) 'Lotta Love' - Wow. This actually rocks pretty much better than anything so far. Well, maybe rocks is the wrong word - swings might be the way to go. Again (you're probably getting tired of me mentioning them) the backing vocals are great. Underrated song. Better than the album version, easily.
9.010) 'Sedan Delivery' - "Let's play some rock and roll!" Yeah - damn right. Just as furious as the album cut, and just as great. The one Neil song I could see the Stooges covering. Not so much punk, as primal rock.
9.011) 'Powderfinger' - Still a masterpiece. Actually I don't think I've ever heard a version of this song that made me think it was less than a masterpiece. Maybe the versions from 2000 with Jim Keltner on drums - dude just didn't seem to know how to play it. But I digress. Here? It's still brilliant.
10.012) 'Cortez the Killer' - Wow. Oops. What the fuck is up with the reggae shtick? That's just embarrassing. Funny how one little part of the song can ruin it and it still remains (mostly) great. Testament to Neil and his guitar. They save this from a trainwreck.
6.013) 'Cinnamon Girl' - Great save. Still crunches as every good version should.
9.014) 'Like a Hurricane' - Lacks a bit of punch at the start, but soon picks it up. At its best (and normal), this song is a masterpiece, at worst it strives to be brilliant. This version is somewhere in between. It soars it spots and falls in others.
9.015) 'Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)' - Just as good as on
Rust Never Sleeps, maybe with a bit more kick to it. Still great.
9.016) 'Tonight's the Night' - Wow. Unexpected. I prefer this to the album version. Is that blasphemous? If so, I don't care - it's what I think. Not the best version I've heard, but definitely not the worst and a very good way to end the album.
9.0ALBUM RATING:
8.0VERDICT: There's a trend in music to like whatever you hear first. Maybe you grew up in a family that was more country than rock and roll and was raised on the Flying Burrito Brothers' version of 'Wild Horses', going years before ever hearing the Stones give it a crack... and as a result you prefer what you're most familiar with. Well, in the world of Neil Young, popular opinion suggests that
Live Rust is far superior to
Weld. And that's simply not the case (as far as I'm concerned). But let's not focus on that too much more, let's focus on what we have here. The 'problem' with
Live Rust is that there's too many songs I was never a big fan of to begin with (and when three of them kick off the album, then that's not a good sign) and there's simply not enough Crazy Horse. And when the songs they're on start playing - it's almost as though there's too much sheen on the tracks, and we all know Crazy Horse aren't a 'sheen' band, they deal in 'crunch'. But... I'm really nitpicking aren't I? There's definitive (so far) versions of 'Sugar Mountain', 'The Loner' and 'Lotta Love' among others, and we finally get to hear a 'Tonight's the Night' played by Crazy Horse - who (IMHO) are the only guys who know what it does (or doesn't) take to play this song properly. And if all this sounds like I don't really care for the album, well then that's the wrong impression to take from this. I like
Live Rust plenty, flaws and all. It's actually one of the finest live albums going around, however of Neil's three live albums with the Horse, it's my third favourite. Go figure!
NEXT: Paul Walker stars in "Neil: The Misunderstood Years".